Portfolio perspectives
Expert Perspective
|November 17, 2026
Expert Perspective
|November 17, 2026
Overview
In this edition:
One of the tougher conversations for advisors starts with a tax bill a client didn’t see coming. And that bill can arrive even when the client hasn’t sold any shares.
That surprise could be especially pronounced this year. Preliminary Vanguard analysis suggests 2026 capital gains distributions could be double their 2021 to 2025 average and about 60% higher than last year.
The size of this year’s increase is more than a year-end communication challenge for advisors. It raises a question about how much of a client’s tax experience can be shaped well before year-end. The answer may depend not just on what clients own, but on how those investments are implemented and where they’re held as well.
Sources: Vanguard calculations, based on preliminary capital gains distribution estimates from YCharts for 2026 and total portfolio allocations based on Morningstar, Inc., data for active and passive equity, fixed income, and balanced mutual funds and ETFs available from 2021 to 2025, as of November 5, 2026.
Behind the increase
After four years of an equity bull market, with the S&P 500 returning 114%,1 many funds are sitting on sizable gains. ETFs can generally limit capital gains distributions more effectively than mutual funds. For mutual funds, those gains can come into play when managers rebalance, trim long-held winners, or reposition portfolios. Selling appreciated holdings along the way can result in distributions to shareholders.
But portfolio management isn't the only source of selling. Investor redemptions can also force managers to raise cash. Among the 50 funds with the largest estimated 2026 distributions, nearly half had lost more than 25% of their assets to outflows, according to Morningstar, Inc.
Those outflows are also happening as investor behavior changes. Active ETFs have grown at a 50% annual rate since 2019,2 expanding the ways investors can access active strategies. At the same time, about 4.1 million Americans are turning 65 this year,3 potentially putting more investors in a position to draw down retirement assets. Neither trend explains this year’s distributions on its own, but both provide context for the changing flows active mutual funds are navigating.
Advisors can't control what's driving distributions, but portfolio construction can influence how clients experience them.
Look beneath the average
In 2025, Vanguard's analysis of advisor portfolios found that the average portfolio distributed 0.69% in capital gains. That's lower than the broader fund data shown in the chart above, but even among these advisor portfolios, the average masks meaningful differences by investment vehicle. Portfolios heavily invested in mutual funds distributed 1.42%, roughly 35 times the level of portfolios primarily invested in ETFs. The difference was also pronounced across asset classes, with equities distributing 1.13% compared with just 0.02% for fixed income.4
Put that 1.42% mutual fund distribution in dollar terms, and the potential impact becomes easier to see. On a hypothetical $2 million portfolio, that would equal $28,400 in capital gains distributions before accounting for the client's individual tax circumstances. Two clients pursuing similar investment goals can therefore face very different tax consequences depending on how their portfolios are constructed.
The transition trade-off
The advisor’s challenge is that improving a portfolio’s future tax efficiency can carry a tax cost today. For clients with sizable unrealized gains, a wholesale move from mutual funds into ETFs could itself trigger a taxable event. That means advisors need to consider not just the potential benefit of a change, but the cost of getting there.
That puts the focus on managing the transition rather than simply choosing one vehicle over another. For existing holdings, advisors might harvest losses elsewhere when appropriate or gradually transition positions. For new money, they can be more deliberate from the start about whether to use a mutual fund or ETF and whether to hold an investment in a taxable or tax-advantaged account.
The goal isn’t to avoid capital gains distributions at all costs. It’s to weigh the potential tax consequences of both staying put and making a change alongside the client’s investment objectives.
Tax efficiency can take different forms depending on the client and portfolio. From ETFs to Vanguard Personalized Indexing (VPI) and the Dynamic Tax Aware ETF Model, Vanguard offers a range of approaches for incorporating tax considerations into portfolio construction.
From insight into action
This year's larger distributions give advisors a reason to take a closer look at taxable portfolios, both for what can still be done now and what could be done differently going forward.
Capital gains distributions may arrive near year-end, but getting ahead of the next tax conversation can start much earlier.
Ask your Vanguard representative to set up a consultation with a portfolio specialist and get preliminary distribution figures by fund and across your portfolios. From there, our team can walk through the results and discuss potential rebalancing opportunities or comparable alternatives.
DOWNLOAD
DOWNLOAD
For additional expert insights, check out:
1 Vanguard calculations from November 2022 through November 11, 2026.
2 Vanguard calculations, based on Morningstar, Inc., data, as of June 30, 2026.
3 Social Security Administration.
4 Vanguard and Morningstar, Inc., as of December 31, 2025.
Notes: